I chose the book God and the Gay Christian because it appears to be the most popular book on the topic. I can see the appeal of the book. It is written in a simple and endearing style. Further, the author, Matthew Vines, argues for the authority of Scripture throughout. I got the chance to spend some quality time with Matthew Vines earlier this year at a conference, and it was clear through both our interactions and his writing that Matthew is a sincere man who engages this conversation with grace. Matthew takes Scripture seriously, and he argues for affirmation of same-sex marriage because he truly believes that is the redemptive vision of Scripture and the most loving posture the church can have toward gay people. Here is a summary of his main points.
God and the Gay Christian received mixed reviews, with many praising its thoughtful approach to reconciling Christianity and same-sex relationships. Supporters found Vines' arguments compelling and biblically grounded, appreciating his respectful tone and personal story. To be fair, many Christians now support same-sex relationships. But those who do tend to see Scripture as a helpful but dated guidebook, not as the final authority on questions of morality and doctrine. That means I believe all of Scripture is inspired by God and authoritative in my life.
God and the Gay Christian is well-written, thoroughly researched, and engaging, but it suffers from a failure to honestly assess all the evidence. While claiming to be evangelical, Vines has ignored key details in the biblical text and has allowed modern assumptions about the need for romantic and sexual relationships to shape his view. Some of my previous university students, many of them bright students, have embraced the view that homosexuality is biblically acceptable. I have seen this trend especially among those who either embraced homosexuality themselves or are close to others who have embraced this lifestyle. In a conversation with one of the students recently, she indicated that I needed to read more on the topic.
God and the Gay Christian Summary Reassessing the essential biblical passages and teachings concerning gender, sexuality, and interpersonal relationships. The story of Sodom and Gomorrah describes a situation where a crowd tried to commit sexual violence, which does not act as a condemnation of same-sex relationships. My understanding is that this book is essentially the extended write-up of his video addressing the topic, which apparently went viral a year or so ago. I must have missed it! Regular readers will know that I have devoted a reasonable amount of time and energy to this topic, and so have an inherent interest in considering new approaches, books and angles on this incredibly important set of questions.